Last week Joseph Makwela, South Africa’s first electric bass player, passed away. I had the honour of working with this musical legend and getting to know him personally. As a tribute to the old master, I wrote an in memoriam with some memories of our encounters.
Joseph Makwela (1940-2023)
“Is Joseph Makwela alive?” I asked, surprised. Across from me sat the legendary singer Hilda Tloubatla of the Mahotella Queens. I was interviewing her in Johannesburg for a radio documentary in 2010. “Yeah, but he’s old eh,” she replied, her face slightly pinched, as if she wanted to spare me a disappointment. Joseph Makwela was the very first electric bass guitarist in South Africa, and with his unique playing style he changed the soundtrack of his country forever. A musical legend in the most literal sense of the word, who, against all my expectations, would become a good musical friend.
Before Joseph, every bass player in South Africa played upright bass, but he was too small of stature for it. So in the early ’60s his close friend West Nkosi gave Joseph an electric bass guitar that a local music shop had just imported from America. Together with West Nkosi on pennywhistle and saxophone, drummer Lucky Monama, and Marks Mankwane and Vivian Ngubane on guitar, Joseph formed the Makgona Tsohle Band. From the ’60s onwards this band became the house band of Gallo Records, South Africa’s biggest record company. They played on thousands of LPs and singles and backed countless artists. But the Makgona Tsohle Band became best known for their collaboration with singer Simon “Mahlathini” Nkabinde and the vocal group the Mahotella Queens. This line-up was the most popular exponent of mbaqanga, a melting pot of musical influences from all the different cultures that came together in the townships through forced migration under apartheid. Mahlathini, nicknamed the ‘Lion of Soweto’ for his deep growling voice, sang call and response with the sparkling harmonies of the Mahotella Queens. The Makgona Tsohle Band laid down a hypnotic mbaqanga groove into which Marks and Vivian effortlessly wove their guitar lines. The beating heart of the band, though, was Joseph’s agile bass playing. High up the neck he commented on the music with lyrical melodies, only to return to low, driving bass lines. Until the late ’70s the Makgona Tsohle Band toured southern Africa relentlessly with Mahlathini and the Mahotella Queens, filling stadiums with their mbaqanga hits. Thanks to the success of Paul Simon’s album Graceland in 1986, on which he reworked several South African songs into catchy pop songs, the Makgona Tsohle Band gained international recognition. Together with Mahlathini and the Mahotella Queens, Joseph and his bandmates toured the world for years. In the late ’90s West Nkosi, Marks Mankwane and Mahlathini died in quick succession, which meant the sudden end of the Makgona Tsohle Band. The Mahotella Queens kept touring and recording, but Joseph withdrew to his little house in Pimville, Soweto, and disappeared off the radar.
Although I was born in Amsterdam, I grew up with the Makgona Tsohle Band; their music was played a lot in our house when I was young. Before I could even walk, I was bouncing to their music. In that sense my meeting with Hilda was already very special, but the chance to get in touch with Joseph came completely out of the blue. When Hilda handed me Joseph’s phone number on a crumpled piece of paper, my heart started beating faster, as if the Makgona Tsohle Band had shifted into third gear so the Mahotella Queens could show off one of their explosive dance routines. Nervously, I dialled the number. On the other end of the line a friendly, crackling voice confirmed that he was indeed Joseph Makwela, and to my great joy I was welcome to come by for an interview. Joseph hadn’t played bass in a long time. After losing his musical friends, he no longer had any ambition to join another band. He didn’t even have an LP or CD of the Makgona Tsohle Band in the house. Joseph looked a little gloomy, but he spoke passionately about his musical adventures. After the interview I raced to a local CD shop to buy a few Makgona Tsohle Band CDs, and before flying back to the Netherlands I gave them to Joseph. “I will keep these until I die!” Joseph grinned, his eyes sparkling. I wasn’t sure I would ever see him again.
Five years later I returned to South Africa for my project Soweto Soul, a tribute to the musical legends of the townships. Together with filmmakers Jesse Bom and Bart Verhoeven I made a documentary about the project, in which I brought together different generations of South African musicians to create new music. Besides capturing Joseph’s fascinating life story, I wanted to find a way to involve him musically. I didn’t know whether he was still able to play in the studio or on stage, but I was determined to persuade him to pick up the bass guitar one more time. After some gentle persuasion, Joseph agreed to take part in a recording session in the studio of Hammond organist and producer Black Moses Ngwenya, bandleader of the Soul Brothers. The two knew each other well; as a child, Black Moses always got a T-shirt or some other souvenir from Joseph’s world tours. The music of the Makgona Tsohle Band had a huge influence on the Soul Brothers, who became wildly popular in South Africa from the ’70s onwards. Also present at the session was Lemmy Special Mabaso, a pennywhistle player who rose to great fame as a teenager in the ’50s and had in turn inspired Joseph to make music. Joseph and Lemmy hadn’t seen each other in years. Their reunion turned into a warm embrace with a lot of shouting. They could hardly believe the other was still alive.
Joseph was no longer in top form. He gave it his best, but played the bass lines more simply than he would have in his heyday. Every now and then he tried a more complex melodic line, but as soon as he threatened to fly off the road, he grumbled his way back to the basic part. Slowly but surely the old master’s stiff fingers loosened up, and together we recorded the song ‘Jive Makwela’, which puts Joseph’s bass playing centre stage. On later trips to South Africa I always tried to involve Joseph in my projects. We shared the stage at a jazz club in Johannesburg, and he took part in the presentation of the Soweto Soul project in South Africa. At his request I always let him know in advance when I was coming, so he could start practising in time to loosen up his fingers. Our reunions were always warm and heartfelt.
When I returned to South Africa earlier this year after a long time away, I called Joseph ahead of time as usual. His daughter told me he was asleep and unwell; what exactly was wrong never became quite clear to me. Among other things, I had come to Johannesburg for recording sessions with Themba Monkoena, an old jazz guitarist who has perfectly mastered the mbaqanga guitar style of the Makgona Tsohle Band. How amazing would it be to bring Joseph in and, just for a moment, bring the legendary sound of the Makgona Tsohle Band back to life? After a few attempts I finally got Joseph on the phone. He sounded weak. He said he wasn’t feeling too well and kindly declined the session. I wished him a speedy recovery and we agreed to meet on my next visit to South Africa. That next time will never come. Last week Joseph passed away, surrounded by his family, at the age of 83. A family member brought me the sad news in a personal message on social media.
During my last visit to South Africa, my good friend and music producer Dr. Sipho Sithole and I discussed the idea of a special concert with South Africa’s living musical legends, above all to put Joseph in the spotlight. Those plans will now go ahead as a posthumous tribute to one of the most influential musicians South Africa has ever known. Meanwhile, West Nkosi, Vivian Ngubane and Marks Mankwane will be glad to finally have their bass player back.
Below is a short trailer with footage of Joseph from the documentary “Soweto Soul”, edited by Jesse Bom.
